[1]王雪丹.试论破产程序与执行程序的竞争与共生[J].江西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2018,(05):124-133.
 WANG Xuedan.On Competition and Symbiosis of the Procedures of Bankruptcy and Execution[J].,2018,(05):124-133.
点击复制

试论破产程序与执行程序的竞争与共生()
分享到:

《江西师范大学学报》(哲学社会科学版)[ISSN:1006-6977/CN:61-1281/TN]

卷:
期数:
2018年05期
页码:
124-133
栏目:
法学探讨
出版日期:
2018-10-20

文章信息/Info

Title:
On Competition and Symbiosis of the Procedures of Bankruptcy and Execution
文章编号:
1000-579(2018)05-0124-10
作者:
王雪丹
广东财经大学 法学院,广东 广州 510320
Author(s):
WANG Xuedan
School of Law,Guangdong University of Finance and Economics,Guangzhou,Guangdong 510320,China
关键词:
执行程序 破产程序 竞争 共生
Keywords:
procedure of execution procedure of bankruptcy competition symbiosis
分类号:
D922.291.92,D915.18
文献标志码:
A
摘要:
执行程序与破产程序的衔接是司法实践中的一大难点。大量执行不能案件难以转入破产程序,表面上看是程序操作问题,实质上却反映了破产法的实施效果不佳。破产不是单纯的法律或财务会计问题,而是复杂的社会问题和经济现象。要通过破产来解决执行难的问题,不应仅仅着眼于执行程序与破产程序衔接的具体程序设计,更要从根本上消除破产制度的基础性缺陷,增强破产制度的竞争力。本文围绕破产程序与执行程序的竞争与共生关系,从利益对立的视角来分析执行程序被过度使用而破产程序被束之高阁的原因,指出必须从经济发展大局的高度来重视破产制度,通过统一各方利益、提升破产制度的吸引力来实现破产程序与执行程序的平衡与共生。
Abstract:
The connection between the procedure of execution and that of bankruptcy has been a great problem in judicial practice.A large number of cases that cannot be performed can hardly turned into the procedure of bankruptcy.On the surface,it seemingly results from the problem of procedure operation,but in fact,it reflects the ineffective implementation of the bankruptcy law.Bankruptcy is not a purely legal or financial accounting issue,but a complex social issue and an economic phenomenon.When solving the difficulty of execution via bankruptcy,we not only need to focus on the concrete procedure of the connection between the procedures of execution and bankruptcy,but also should fundamentally eliminate the basic defects of bankruptcy system and enhance its competitiveness.This paper focuses on the relationship of competition and symbiosis between the procedures of execution and bankruptcy,trying to analyze from the perspective of interest antagonism the reason why the procedure of bankruptcy is put on shelf in contrast of overuse of the procedure of execution,and points out that it is necessary to pay attention to the bankruptcy system from the height of economic development.We should realize the balance and symbiosis between the procedures of execution and bankruptcy by unifying the interests of the parties and enhancing the attractiveness of the bankruptcy system.

参考文献/References:

[1]王 峰.2016年法院受理破产案件激增助力“僵尸企业”出清[N].21世纪经济报道,2016-12-07(6).
[2]杜万华.充分认识执行案件依法移送破产审查工作重要意义[N].人民法院报,2017-12-11(2).
[3]Charlotte Denny.2002,Japan's zombie economy-not buying but browsing[N].the Guardian,20 November.
[4]温信祥.降社会融资成本重在结构性改革(下)[N].第一财经日报,2014-09-19(B05).
[5]曹思源.金融危机下中国企业破产法被束之高阁——曹思源接受《法人》杂志记者马丽的独家专访[EB/OL].http://www.aisixiang.com/data/27281.html,2009-05-17/2017-01-13.
[6]万 敏.全国破产案件为何不增反减?专家呼吁设个人破产制度[N].每日经济新闻,2016-06-15(3).
[7]刘效仁.破产庭有助于“僵尸企业”依法退市[N].人民法院报,2016-08-17(2).
[8]王 峰,李伊琳.部分民企“跑路”与破产的法律选择[N].21世纪经济报道,2014-09-04(2).
[9]曹思源.破产立案数据的差异意味着什么[EB/OL].http://www.aisixiang.com/data/19216.html,2008-06-16/2017-01-13.
[10]刘子阳.今年已结破产类案件同比增长逾七成[N].法制日报,2017-12-27(3).
[11]黄金龙.民事执行参与分配制度中的争议问题[N].人民法院报,2007-08-03(6).
[12]赵万一,高 达.论我国个人破产制度的构建[J].法商研究,2014,(3).
[13]陈荣宗.强制执行法(修订二版)[M].台北:三民书局,2007.
[14]王欣新,徐阳光.中国破产法的困境与出路——破产案件数量下降的原因及应对[J].商事审判指导,2014,(1).
[15]张元华.论执行移送破产程序的激励性引导与规制[J].甘肃政法学院学报,2016,(6).
[16]胡志光,白田甜,景晓晶.执行案件移送破产审查的路径规范——以深圳法院实践为样本[J].人民司法(运用),2017,(19).
[17]胡彦宇.国内破产企业债务清偿率统计研究[EB/OL].http://finance.ce.cn/rolling/201404/09/t20140409_2627094.shtml,2014-04-09/2018-01-23.
[18]齐树洁,陈洪杰.破产程序与执行程序的冲突及其协调[J].厦门大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2007,(3).
[19]韩长印.破产程序的财产分配与价值增值规则[J].法商研究,2002,(3).
[20]曹思源.企业破产案穿14年最低的反思[J].沪港经济,2010,(1).
[21]崔国栋.执行程序与破产程序衔接机制问题的调研[EB/OL].http://www.chinacourt.org/article/detail/2016/05/id/1849867.shtml,2016-05-03/2017-01-15.
[22]李 帅.论执行案件中法院职权主义破产启动程序的构建[J].法学论坛,2015,(11).
[23]徐建新,汝明钰.执行程序与破产程序衔接机制的实务探索[N].人民法院报,2015-6-10(8).
[24]Jason J.Kilborn.Mercy,Rehabilitation,and Quid Pro Quo:A Radical Reassessment of Individual Bankruptcy[J].Ohio St.L.J.2003,(855).
[25]杨晓宴.一封法院副院长给“两会”的建言信:个人破产立法是化解债务危机的必要选择[N].21世纪经济报道,2016-3-11(10).
[26]游春亮,王东兴.深圳率先解决破产企业注销难题[N].法制日报,2016-6-16(3).
[27]王 山.大数据时代中国政府治理能力建设与公共治理创新[J].求实,2017,(1).

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:
收稿日期:2018-06-20
基金项目:广东省2017年度全省法院重点调研课题“执行程序与破产程序衔接制度研究”
作者简介:王雪丹(1980-),女,广东汕头人,法学硕士,广东财经大学法治与经济发展研究所副研究员,广东财经大学法学院副教授,硕士生导师。研究方向为商法。
更新日期/Last Update: 2018-10-20